I've just booked a round trip ticket to Boston on American Airlines using Qantas frequent flier miles. It cost me a mere 16,000 points, a $5 fee, and two minutes of my time online. Those of you who have tried to use frequent flier miles recently will appreciate how terrific this is.
I've rarely booked a trip using frequent flier miles. For one thing, I generally get the cheapest possible tickets, which means that I don't get many points (some aren't even eligible for points), and the points I do get are scattered across a few different frequent flier programs. For another thing, as any of you who've tried to use frequent flier points recently will know, it tends to be a real pain in the butt to book flights with miles. Most of the programs have upped the miles one needs to get a free flight, attached all kinds of fees, and limited the dates you can fly and the available seats until it's just about impossible to use your miles, and not particularly worthwhile when it is possible. Most programs require an absolute minimum of 25,000 miles to book a round trip flight within the U.S., and these days, it's usually more (sometimes a lot more).
Well, not with Qantas miles. My flight from New York to Boston cost me 8000 Qantas points each way (yes! you can book a one-way ticket with a mere 8000 points!), and a whopping $2.50 booking fee. What's more, with the Qantas program, you can book award flights at the last minute, assuming there's room on the flight, with no fee for doing so. Better yet, it's quick and easy to book award flights -- I booked online in about two minutes, and one minute later was holding an e-ticket in my hot little hands.
Here's what's a little crazy about this: I earned my 24,000 Qantas miles on my trip to Australia, taking Qantas/American Airlines codeshare flights. I could have received the same number of American Airlines miles for those same flights. I didn't do so because some glitch in the system was refusing to accept my brand-spanking-new AA frequent flier number, and since I had no miles accumulated in that program anyway, and rarely if ever have had occasion to fly with American, I shrugged and went with Qantas.
(ASIDE: For those of you who are not frequent fliers and don't already know, most airlines these days are part of big airline alliances. If you fly with any airline in the alliance, you can get points for your flights on any frequent flier program for any other airline in the alliance, not just the airline with which you flew. And you can use your points on any other airline in the alliance, regardless of the program you chose to participate in. Nifty, huh? The one thing you can't do, unfortunately, is combine points on different programs to purchase a ticket. If you have 10,000 points on one program in the alliance, and 20,000 on another, and need 30,000 for your ticket, you're out of luck. )
But get this -- if I had chosen to receive American Airlines miles instead of Qantas miles for my flights on my Australia trip, I would not have had enough miles to book this trip to Boston on American Airlines. It would have cost me 25,000 to 50,000 American miles to book an economy class ticket, depending on the timing of my flight, and my Australia trip entitled me to only 24,831 miles. So, in order to get my ticket, I would have had to buy 1000 additional miles (the minimum amount you can buy) for $27.50, plus pay a $30 processing fee, and thenwait 72 hours for those miles to post to my American frequent flyer account. Plus I'd have to pay a minimum $20 booking fee -- oh wait, since I'm booking within 21 days of my flight, it would be a $50 booking fee. (If I'd waited until within 6 days of my flight, it would be a $100 fee).
So -- if I'd taken American miles instead of Qantas miles for my Australia ticket, I'd have to pay $107.50 to get my "free" ticket to Boston -- just about enough to buy a round trip ticket without using points! -- and I'd have had to use all the miles in my frequent flier account to do it. But because I took Qantas miles, I paid only $5 for exactly the same round trip ticket to Boston, and I still have 8000 miles left -- which believe it or not, is enough to get me another one-way ticket to Boston (with another $2.50 booking fee, of course).
FYI, my 24,000 Qantas points would also have been enough for a round trip ticket from NYC to Chicago or to Miami -- those trips would have cost me 12,000 Qantas points for each leg, plus the $2.50 booking fee. However, I did not have enough Qantas points to get me to California or Dallas. If I'd wanted a round trip ticket to California, I probably would have been better off if I'd chosen American points for my Australian trip. Weird, isn't it?
The trick is this: The Qantas program determines the number of frequent flier miles required for a free trip by the number of miles you plan to fly on the free trip -- it charges you fewer points for shorter trips (which makes sense, doesn't it?). American, on the other hand, charges exactly the same number of points for any domestic flight, whether it is 200 miles or 3000 miles. With American miles, a round-trip flight between Boston and NYC would require the same amount of points as a trip to California -- 25,000 to 50,000, depending on the date of the flights. With Qantas miles, a round-trip flight between Boston and NYC would require 16,000 points, but to California, it would require 50,000. Oh, and with the Qantas program, you can use miles for one-way trips, which you can't on American. (One-way trips up to 600 miles cost 8000 points, one-way trips from 601 -- 1200 miles cost 12,000 points, one-way trips from 1201 -2400 miles cost 18,000 points, one-way trips from 2401 - 3600 miles cost 25,000 points, and so forth. http://www.qantas.com.au/fflyer/dyn/program/usingPoints/pointsTables )
So the upshot is this: If you often fly American or its airline partners (including Qantas), and you want to use your miles for longer flights, you might be better off getting American Airlines points for your flights. However, if you don't often fly those airlines, or if you think you'll want to use your points for shorter flights or one-way flights, you are unquestionably way, way better off getting Qantas points for your flights.
I really should start charging for my travel advice.